Sign into the game





 Which player is better
 
1
Simplon
22:07:15, 27.01.21

Which 17y is better: Q:97/P:82 or Q:91/P:88?

09:54:05, 31.01.21

how we could know it, only from Q/P ?

Simplon
12:09:30, 31.01.21

Isn't Q and P the only thing that matters at age 17? Let's say they have the same AI and the same distribution of skills.

14:21:58, 31.01.21

you know, it depends on AI, on attributes, position- W,C, D, G :) and also his loyality ...
but ok.. for me Better Q

Keiris
11:26:00, 01.02.21

In my approximations, the differenve between a season of potential is abou 4-5 Q points. So in this case Q97 P82 is better. Probably :)

11:45:18, 01.02.21

yes, Q97 has better average training in comparison to Q 91... so this possibility to have one more season for training is no so big deal :)

17:39:57, 01.02.21

Also when a player gets old and is on 0 pot, he has a chance of extending his 0 pot for seasons.

jetsdude|HA
18:27:30, 01.02.21

Also, players who aren't max P will decline slower than better P players (-5 instead of -6, etc.)

07:46:03, 02.02.21

Quality values more, since now you can increase all other aspects of player.. (:

Pavel Burek
06:36:46, 21.12.21

Two wingers, both are the same age and have the same AI. One has 94/max and the other 97/max-1. Which one is better option in the long term?

The post has been deleted

islander1
15:34:04, 21.12.21

Pavel Burek 06:36:46, 21.12.21 Two wingers, both are the same age and have the same AI. One has 94/max and the other 97/max-1. Which one is better option in the long term?

Depends on if you care about championships and resale value.

If your next rebuild really predicates selling your players before they lose value, I'd keep the MAX guy since that's one more year you can win a title and still have better re-sale value.

This is assuming equal loyalty, of course.

15:38:56, 21.12.21

Trsto 11:45:18, 01.02.21 yes, Q97 has better average training in comparison to Q 91... so this possibility to have one more season for training is no so big deal :)

Another important aspect can be U20 national team. Is it NT year or not..

Q97 guy have better chances to get into u20 team, so he can have more AI and more experience as well.

15:40:37, 21.12.21

islander1 15:34:04, 21.12.21 the other 97/max-1. Which one is better option in the long term?

Depends on if you care about championships and resale value.

If your next rebuild really predicates selling your players before they lose value, I'd keep the MAX guy since that's one more year you can win a title and still have better re-sale value.

This is assuming equal loyalty, of course.


I agree with you, but with +6 POT jerseys, 97/max-1 can potentiality be 97/max..

islander1
19:15:38, 21.12.21

izy7 15:40:37, 21.12.21 if you care about championships and resale value.

If your next rebuild really predicates selling your players before they lose value, I'd keep the MAX guy since that's one more year you can win a title and still have better re-sale value.

This is assuming equal loyalty, of course.

I agree with you, but with +6 POT jerseys, 97/max-1 can potentiality be 97/max..


Of course, in that scenario :)


 
1